1 Comment

Dear Jordan,

Thanks for this thought-provoking list.

In my view, the task you've set yourself can be rephrased as follows: "What does it mean to be a person in the world of AI?" Or to put it another way, "When our purely cognitive capacities have been bested by machines, where shall we discover our value as human beings?"

I think we agree that lawyers, if they are to be anything, must be people first and foremost -- AI will take care of the rest.

My own list of 10 is as follows:

Conscience and self-control

Disposition to learn (for lawyers this means learning the current state of the law); awareness of the mutability of knowledge (for lawyers, the law's constant flux)

Analytical thinking

Metaphorical thinking

Assertiveness; willingness to face conflict if necessary

Flexibility; willingness to find common ground

Capacity to live with, and tack between, incompatible rules, values, priorities, ideas

Imagination; creativity; “thinking outside the box”

Awareness of one’s own feelings; calmness; centeredness

Locating within oneself what others feel; empathy; relatedness

From these attributes flow the essential legal skills: Disaggregating problems; discovering solutions; advising; advocating; negotiating; planning; and strategizing.

Expand full comment